If You’re Going to Leave Your Church, Do It Right

We looked at how to begin at your new church. But sometimes the harder move is leaving your old church. I don’t want to give advice on when to leave a church.

Let’s assume the reasons make sense, and now the question is how to leave. What should you do?

1. Try to leave graciously.

When someone voluntarily leaves a church (not because of a move or a graduation or a deployment), it is usually a painful experience. You’ve probably been hurt or disappointed. Maybe you dislike the new pastor or the new direction of the church.

The temptation in these situations will be toward bitterness. You may want to leave with all your guns ablazin’, but the approach that feels good isn’t always the one that is good. Better to err on the side of gentleness and let the Lord repay your enemies. This also makes it easier for you to admit wrong if you should find some down the road.

2. Tell the pastor you are leaving.

This may be the most important point. Please let someone know you are going. You may want people to notice you are gone, and a good elder board will notice, but if you’ve already decided to leave, now is not the time for sour grapes.

If you tell the leaders you are leaving, they can pray for you. Maybe they can clear up a misunderstanding. Or maybe they need to learn from your experience. Just don’t go silently into that good night.

3. Leave off a ledge.

I got this imagery from a dear member who recently left our church and did so with great grace and magnanimity. He told me that, as he thought about leaving, he decided he didn’t want to drift away, slowly pulling away and dropping his commitments. He said he’d rather take a leap off the ledge and be fully engaged until the moment when he decided it was time to go.

Be in while you are in, and then when you are out, jump right out.

4. Learn how to kindly and honestly answer the question, “Why did you leave?”

People will ask you, so figure out your answer. Don’t kill someone’s character or disembowel the whole church with your reply. Don’t lie either.

A simple, straightforward answer will suffice. We didn’t agree with the direction of the church. We disagreed with some of the doctrines being taught. We didn’t feel like we could submit ourselves to the authority of the church any longer. Tell the truth, but speak it in the manner you would want the church to speak about you.

Previous articleWhat Not to Say after a Sermon
Next article6 Lessons for More Creative Teaching
Kevin DeYoung
Kevin is the Senior Pastor at University Reformed Church (RCA) in East Lansing, Michigan, right across the street from Michigan State University. He has been the pastor there since 2004.

Get the ChurchLeaders Daily Sent to Your Inbox