Should You Write Your Own Ministry Curriculum?

When I first started out in youth ministry, I couldn’t find a curriculum that worked for my youth group. At that time (back when dinosaurs roamed the earth), I didn’t have this little resource called the Internet. Even when it became a popular in the late ’90s, it wasn’t exactly convenient—remember waiting for all of the dial-up beeps, hums and whirs? In those days, we had to look through a physical catalogue or take a trip to a store to purchase any kind of usable curriculum.

Beyond that, there were three more complications to finding anything in physical form. First, I started my youth ministry career in rural New Hampshire, about as far as you could get from the Bible Belt. Our “Christian bookstore” was a small basement someone had converted into a space where we could buy Bibles and cassette tapes of then-unknown bands like Third Day, Audio Adrenaline, Jars of Clay and DC Talk.

Second, I felt as if I lived behind a dark shroud of knowledge. No one was mass marketing to one of the most unchurched areas in the country. In the early ’90s, no one was aware of companies like Youth Specialties, Group Publishing or even Lifeway.

Third, here is the kicker: There was no money in our budget for luxury items like books about games or discussion starters. In my first years of ministry, I was a volunteer youth pastor of four church plants who sent all of their students to me, but limited financial resources.

It wasn’t until 1997 that I finally had the opportunity to try out a professional curriculum—four boxes of resources given to me as a free gift from some very generous youth workers at a conference. It was like Christmas.

Yet, using this curriculum still proved a challenge. I worked with all unchurched or de-churched kids, and most of the resource was written for students who grew up in the church and knew the basic tenants of the faith. Everything was in print back then (no digital copies) so to manipulate curriculum meant taking out a pen and Wite-Out, and literally rewriting it. It was cumbersome and time consuming. Keep in mind that the idea of small groups being central to youth group was still relatively new. Youth workers were starting to catch on, but that wasn’t how most curriculums were written. They were built around a creative game, an awesome talk and finally—if there was any time left to kill—a little time for a discussion. I felt like I was the only youth worker in the country who built my lessons around small groups.

For all of these reasons, I took the plunge and started writing my own curriculum. But that introduced all new struggles. It was easier to look at an idea in a book and see it as catalytic than it was to manipulate it into my own lessons. And I didn’t realize that I was starting to become proud about my curriculum-writing abilities. I was the best lesson writer of anyone, anywhere, and no one could tell me differently.

Then one day my volunteers told me it wasn’t so good. That was hard to hear. Looking back, I now understand it wasn’t because I wasn’t capable of writing great stuff. I was just too busy to do it well. Writing a solid, easy-to-use Bible study that a volunteer of any experience level can use takes a huge amount of work and time. I wanted to spend my time building relationships with students, teaching my leaders to disciple teens and figuring out how to reach this generation for Christ. I didn’t want to spend hours crafting small group curriculum. So I didn’t, and it showed.

This forced me, once again, to go looking for something that could work in my context. By this time, I could download sheets and change a few words or ideas and hand my team something that bordered on amazing. Some organizations had even started making video curriculum, so on the days I didn’t feel particularly wise, someone else was. And here’s the icing on the cake: The Internet was more accessible, so I could find websites full of ideas, games and discussion starters.

In just the last 10 years, the landscape has changed once again for Bible study curriculum. I don’t have to buy a book if I don’t want to, and if I want a video illustration, I can check out YouTube. I can pick and choose what I like from a multitude of different companies, large and small. I can find lessons and ideas from at least nine places I can think of off the top of my head.

Here is the irony: I keep meeting youth pastors who insist on writing their own curriculum. Some youth workers have the energy and time to do this, but nine times out of 10, they don’t actually enjoy it. Instead I hear, “There is nothing out there, so I have to write my own.” My other favorite line is, “These companies use professional writers who never actually interact with students.” That’s just not true. I know many of these people personally. While they may not all lead youth ministries anymore, each stays connected to the student world in huge ways. They lead small groups, talk to parents and have youth pastors in their offices multiple times a week. More importantly, many of them employ in-the-trenches youth workers as their writers.

There was a time when the boxed set didn’t work. And not every curriculum has everything you need. But the amount of depth and variety out there is astounding compared to when I first started. The youth ministry curriculum landscape has changed completely. It might be helpful to find other youth pastors in a similar context and ask them what they like. You will probably need to rewrite something here or there. Most curriculum providers actually expect that and provide digital resources to make it easier.

So STOP. Ask yourself, Why am I writing my own curriculum?

If your answer is anything less than, I feel called and passionate about it! then STOP living like you are stuck in rural New Hampshire in 1994. Wouldn’t you rather invest your limited time into the lives of students instead of sitting in front of a computer?  

Previous articleMust Haves for New Small Group Leaders
Next articleI Preached 98 Times in 2 Years—Is That Too Much?
Leneita Fix
Leneita Fix is the founder and lead consultant for Blue Sky/Green Sky Consulting whose heart is : ”Passionate about developing and training youth-oriented programs that are looking to take a generation from surviving to thriving in Christ. In 2012 she will reach the 20 year mark of experience in youth ministry, suburban, urban and rural. Most of her time has been spent in the urban community, living as a neighbor to those around her.