Another danger is theological accuracy. AI tools are trained on vast amounts of data but do not possess faith, conviction, or spiritual wisdom. They can generate polished words that may subtly distort biblical meaning or omit critical nuances. A pastor must always evaluate AI suggestions through the lens of Scripture and sound theology. Without careful oversight, there is a risk of preaching messages that are clever but not faithful.
There is also the question of spiritual formation. Sermon preparation is not merely an academic exercise; it is a spiritual discipline. Wrestling with the text, praying for guidance, and meditating on the needs of the congregation are all part of how God shapes the pastor’s heart. If AI shortcuts this process, the preacher may miss out on the personal growth and spiritual depth that come from time spent in the Word. The danger is not just shallow sermons but shallow preachers.
RELATED: Verse-by-Verse Preaching Really Does Matter
Finally, ethical considerations arise. Congregations deserve transparency about how sermons are created. If AI plays a significant role, should pastors disclose this? While AI may assist in research, it cannot replace the unique calling and responsibility of proclaiming God’s Word. Leaders must be careful to use the tool without compromising integrity.
Striking a balance
The challenge, then, is not whether to use AI, but how. Wise pastors will approach the technology as a servant rather than a master. Using AI to help write sermons can be valuable when it supports creativity, accelerates research, or expands resources. But it should never replace the pastor’s responsibility to study, pray, and craft a message that flows from their own walk with God.
Balance means setting boundaries. For instance, a pastor may use AI to gather background information on a biblical text but commit to writing the sermon body themselves. Or they may experiment with AI for brainstorming but ensure that every word spoken reflects their voice and convictions. This kind of thoughtful integration allows pastors to benefit from technology without losing the spiritual depth and authenticity that preaching requires.
The rise of AI presents both perils and perks for the pulpit. On the one hand, using AI to help write sermons can save time, inspire creativity, and provide resources that strengthen preaching. On the other hand, it carries risks of inauthenticity, theological error, and diminished spiritual growth. The key lies in discernment. Pastors must decide how to integrate AI responsibly, using it as a tool to serve the gospel rather than as a crutch that undermines their calling. At its best, AI can be a helpful partner, but only if the preacher remains faithful to the deeper work of prayer, study, and the Spirit’s guidance.
