Attorneys for Morris have said that Gateway leaders knew about the abuse allegations “as early as 2005.”
In their June 29 handout, New Life elders said that after Boyd’s June 8 denial, they received “information from 2011 demonstrating that [Boyd] was party to at least 20 emails relating to Ms. Clemishire’s abuse.”
The elders said “that he interacted extensively with those emails, and that many of the emails stated in the subject line the allegation that Ms. Clemishire was 12 at the time. [Boyd] failed to disclose this to the Board of Elders.”
RELATED: Gateway Church Says Decline in Giving Has Necessitated Staffing Cuts
According to the elders, Clemishire’s sister told the 2007 search committee at New Life what Morris had allegedly done to Clemishire and objected to the Colorado Springs church hiring Boyd.
The handout stated:
[Boyd] also said during his June 8 message [to congregants] that the search committee did not tell him in 2007 the details regarding Ms. Clemishire. However, meeting notes and email records confirmed that the search committee met with [Boyd] specifically to discuss the accusations made by Ms. Clemishire’s sister and then dialogued with him for weeks about the issue.
After reviewing “other new evidence” and talking with Boyd, the elders said they were unable to “reconcile the facts.” They wrote, “As much as we hoped it would all make sense, in the end, it simply didn’t.”
In their earlier statement about Boyd’s resignation, the elders indicated that “trust was broken” between them and the pastor.
Elders: Brady Boyd Is Disqualified From Serving at New Life
In a Q&A about their former senior pastor’s standing, the elders noted, “[Boyd] has not apologized nor is he repentant for what we think constituted lying to New Life Church, or for failing to disclose to the Elders whatever knowledge he had about Robert Morris before asking Morris to serve as overseer and to preach at our church.”
They added, “We believe Brady made a series of mistakes that disqualify him from serving as Senior Pastor of New Life. We do love Brady and consider him a significant contributor to the New Life story.”
