3. The Man Who Confuses Pastoral Care With Romantic Interest
You prayed with him during a crisis. You listened to his marriage struggles. You offered biblical counsel. Now he’s convinced you “understand him like no one else,” including his wife. He begins to view your pastoral care as evidence of a special connection.
Warning: Emotional affairs often begin in the counseling office.
Response: Limit one-on-one sessions to two meetings maximum and then refer him to a male pastor or professional counselor. Never meet alone behind closed doors. Document your interactions if needed.
4. The Man Who Wants You To Fix His Marriage
His marriage is struggling, and he’s convinced that talking to you, a woman, will help him understand his wife better. But instead of working on his marriage, he’s building an emotional relationship with you.
Response: Refer him immediately to a male pastor or licensed counselor. Do not become his confidant. If he’s seeking marriage help, suggest couples counseling, not individual sessions with you.
RELATED: With Beth Moore’s Exit, More Evangelical Women Are Challenging Complementarianism
5. The Man Who Sees You as a Conquest
He’s charming, flattering, and persistent. He may be in leadership himself. He compliments your preaching, your insight, your appearance. He engineers opportunities to be alone with you. His attention feels intoxicating, especially if you’re not receiving affirmation elsewhere.
Warning: Predators exist in the church. Some men view female pastors as a challenge or a trophy.
Response: Run. Do not engage in private conversations, meetings, or correspondence. If he persists, involve church leadership immediately. Protect yourself and document everything.
6. The Man Who Treats You Like “One of the Guys”
He’s on your ministry team, and he treats you casually—maybe too casually. He makes off-color jokes, makes inappropriate comments, and expresses overly familiar physical contact (arm around the shoulder, lingering hugs). He justifies it as “just how I am” or “I don’t see gender.”
Warning: Familiarity breeds compromise. What seems harmless can quickly become inappropriate.
Response: Address it directly and professionally. Set clear boundaries about physical contact and conversational topics. If it continues, involve leadership.
