Every December, families around the world welcome a mischievous little elf into their homes. Elf on the Shelf has become a fun holiday tradition—but many Christian parents wonder if the focus on behavior and rewards sends the right message.
If you love the creativity and excitement of Elf on the Shelf but want to keep Christ at the center of Christmas, you’re not alone. These 10 Christian alternatives to Elf on the Shelf keep the joy and imagination while teaching kids about kindness, giving, and the true meaning of Christmas.
10 Christian Alternatives to Elf on the Shelf
1. Shepherd on the Search
The Shepherd on the Search activity follows a shepherd’s journey to find the baby Jesus. Each day, kids search for the shepherd as he moves closer to the nativity. It’s interactive, faith-filled, and a great way to keep kids focused on the birth of Christ.
2. The Star From Afar
This interactive nativity set includes a wooden star that parents hide daily. Each morning, kids search for the star and move the wise men closer to the stable. The accompanying storybook connects the daily hunt to the biblical Christmas story.
3. The Giving Manger
Instead of focusing on what kids can get, The Giving Manger teaches them to give. Each time a child performs an act of kindness, they place a piece of straw in the manger. By Christmas morning, baby Jesus rests in a bed made of their good deeds.
4. Kindness Elf
Give your elf a new mission—spreading kindness. A “Kindness Elf” can leave notes each morning suggesting simple ways to bless others, like baking cookies for a neighbor, donating toys, or helping a sibling. The focus moves from “being watched” to watching out for others.
5. Advent Angels
Hide small angel figurines around your home, each carrying a short Bible verse or devotion. Every day, your children can find an angel and read a message about hope, peace, joy, or love—reflecting the themes of Advent.
