Mistake #4: Treating the Process Like Corporate Hiring
Resumes, references, and interviews matter. But when the process becomes purely managerial, spiritual discernment fades into the background. Prayer becomes perfunctory. Silence feels unproductive. Efficiency overrides attentiveness.
In Acts 13:2, the church discerns leadership while worshiping and fasting, not while rushing toward a timeline. That does not mean avoiding structure. It means refusing to confuse speed with faithfulness.
Build space into the process for:
-
Corporate prayer that is not agenda-driven
-
Scripture reading that shapes imagination
-
Silence that allows discomfort to surface
God often speaks slowly. Committees need practices that can hear Him.
RELATED: Foundations for Church Unity
Mistake #5: Forgetting the Church Will Need to Change Too
Sometimes a committee unconsciously searches for someone who will adapt to the church without the church adapting at all. The expectation is continuity with a new personality, not shared transformation.
Every pastoral transition is a moment of change, whether acknowledged or not. A new leader brings new emphases, blind spots, and strengths.
Wise committees ask:
-
What might God be asking us to release?
-
Where will we need to grow alongside our next pastor?
-
Are we willing to be led, not just served?
A pastor search committee that assumes mutual transformation is already ahead of the curve.
How a Pastor Search Committee Can Get It Right
Healthy processes do not guarantee easy outcomes, but they create conditions for faithfulness.
Here are practical steps that help:
-
Clarify the church’s mission before evaluating candidates
-
Name non-negotiables and hold them loosely
-
Assign someone to guard the spiritual health of the committee, not just the logistics
-
Refuse pressure to “settle” simply to be done
Above all, remember that discernment is communal. Unity is not unanimity, but it is a shared sense of peace rooted in trust.
A Healthier Way Forward for the Pastor Search Committee
A pastor search committee is not just filling a vacancy. It is stewarding a moment in the life of a church. How the process unfolds will shape trust, expectations, and culture long after a pastor is called.
Move slowly enough to listen. Honestly enough to tell the truth. Humbly enough to admit limits. When committees do that, they stop asking, “Who is the best candidate?” and start asking, “Where is God already at work among us?”
That is the posture that turns a stressful search into a faithful step forward.
