Home Youth Leaders Articles for Youth Leaders How Your Graduating Seniors Can Help You Evaluate Your Ministry

How Your Graduating Seniors Can Help You Evaluate Your Ministry

Sometime in the next two weeks or so, youth workers across the country will process through one of the bigger events on their ministry calendars. Senior graduation. Graduation is a whirlwind time that can hold a variety of different emotions all at once:

  • Stress caused by additional responsibilities at an already busy time of year
  • Happiness and pride for the life transition students are entering into
  • Sadness that this new stage for students means a change in your relationship, and so on …

So, graduation is an important time. But it’s most important for the possibilities that exist for evaluating your ministry. What do I mean? Glad you asked …

Your graduating seniors may represent a chance to evaluate your youth ministry strategy.

While it’s by no means cut and dry, by looking at your seniors, you might just get a glimpse into what students look like having come through your youth ministry. It could be an invaluable way of thinking about your strategy and approach. Here’s what I mean …

Think about your graduates. Think about them as a group and as individuals. As a group, what values do you see them holding that you worked to instill? Are they passionate about the poor and needy? Are they serious about leadership? Are they committed to evangelism? If they have held on to these values, it’s affirmation that you are doing an effective job of teaching, modeling and placing an important emphasis, and/or that you are partnering with their parents to keep these themes present in their lives.

As individuals, do you see the effects of your disciple-making strategy? Do they have a passion for God’s Word? Do they live out their faith visibly? Do they value service? Do they openly talk about their faith? If you can look at your individual students and see signs of the faith development that you and their parents have lead them to develop, then you can have a measure of confidence that your Spirit-led efforts to lead students in discipleship are on the right track.

But what if you look at your graduates and don’t see a group of students who share some or most of your values? What if you don’t see individuals who have grown in their faith?

Again, there are quite a few factors to consider. Maybe you’re relatively new. Maybe you didn’t spend all or most of the time with your graduates over the course of their time in youth ministry. And certainly, you can’t take too much credit or too much blame for the development of your students. Their parents have more to do with their faith development than you. But there are still takeaways when you look at your graduates and see some holes in their spiritual development:

Fine Tune Your Existing Strategy

If you’ve been with your graduates for a few years and see spiritual areas in their lives that aren’t as developed as you like, you might want to make a change in your ministry philosophy. Consider programming and relational approaches that address the specific discipline you find lacking.

Implement a New Strategy

Maybe you are relatively new. Looking at graduates, you see some things that you would like to address. Maybe it’s time to introduce your own strategy, change some things up and focus on a more comprehensive approach to making disciples. It’s a good occasion to kick off a conversation with your leadership.

Build a Better Bridge to Parents

In a perfect world, you are a resource for parents, supplementing their efforts at making disciples. We all know that this only looks like this in a small percentage of students. To see students leave your ministries as spiritually mature disciples of Christ, you need to have an active partnership with students’ parents. Maybe it’s time to lay out the strategy of being more holistic in your approach to discipleship by building strong, equipping relationships with parents.

While it’s not a perfect science, and while there are a variety of variables, your graduating seniors do offer a glimpse into your youth ministry values. It’s information, data, if you will. The challenge is determining whether or not this data can help you facilitate a more effective youth ministry.  

Previous article12 Often Overlooked Practices Great Leaders Develop That Poor Leaders Don’t
Next articleGod Doesn’t Need Cops in the Pulpit—He Needs Preachers
Andy Blanks is the co-founder of youthministry360, a ministry committed to equipping youth workers through resources, training, community, and networking. Andy is passionate about God’s Word and the transformation it brings in the lives of God’s people. Andy is a writer, teacher, speaker, and a lifelong Boston Red Sox fan. He lives in Birmingham, AL with his wife and three daughters. Check out Andy’s youth ministry posts on the ym360 Blog (www.youthministry360.com/blog).