Greear Names 10 Churches in Danger of Disfellowship Over Abuse

J.D. Greear

Following a lengthy investigation into sexual abuse within his denomination’s churches, Southern Baptist Convention President J.D. Greear is calling for reforms, training and more background checks. He’s also leaving open the possibility of developing a registry or database of convicted and credibly accused church leaders and volunteers.

Addressing SBC leaders in Nashville on Monday, Greear acknowledged that abuse reports hadn’t been taken seriously enough and had sometimes been ignored. “There is a problem,” he said, and “it’s time we back up our words with actions.”

Some Churches May Be Ousted

In its three-part series “Abuse of Faith,” the Houston Chronicle (HC) suggests that the self-autonomy of SBC churches may be responsible for the crisis. Greear disputes that, saying autonomy isn’t an excuse for overlooking abuse claims. Yet on Monday, he said SBC churches that don’t “meet the standards of having a faith and practice which closely identifies” with those of the Convention might face removal.

“Churches must be called upon to give assurance to the SBC that they have taken the necessary steps to correct their policies and procedures with regards to abuse and care for survivors,” said Greear. “Our goal here is never disfellowship, but correction.” On CNN Monday, Greear said he, as president, doesn’t have authority to disfellowship a church but that congregational representatives (messengers) attending denominational meetings can vote out an offending church.

Of the 10 churches the HC lists as problematic for how they’ve handled abuse claims, one is Second Baptist in Houston, led by former SBC president Ed Young. The church has denied the allegations. The other churches Greear mentioned are:

Brentwood Baptist Church, Houston, Texas
Cathedral of Faith, Houston, Texas
Arapaho Baptist Church, Garland, Texas
Bolivar Baptist Church, Sanger, Texas
First Baptist Church, Bedford, Texas
Sovereign Grace Church, Louisville, Kentucky
Turner Street Baptist Church, Springdale, Arkansas
Eastside Baptist Church, Marietta, Georgia
Trinity Baptist Church, Ashburn, Georgia

Greear says he supports changing denominational bylaws to more easily remove churches exhibiting a “wanton disregard for sexual abuse.” He also wants more background checks and more resources to help churches assist victims.

Greear Announces New Curriculum

One action step is a free 12-lesson training resource that will be available for ministry leaders in June. “Becoming a Church That Cares Well for the Abused” is being developed by a 10-member team of experts, including pastors, psychologists, social workers and attorneys. One member, victim’s advocate Rachael Denhollander, has spoken out frequently about abuse within churches.

The curriculum has two purposes, Greear says: providing “excellent instruction” regarding the initial stages of pastoral care in abuse cases and modeling “good cooperation” between churches and professionals in the community. The goal, he says, is for churches to “care well for the oppressed and abused” and to serve as a “haven” for survivors. 

‘Every option is on the table’ 

Although Greear didn’t commit to establishing a sex-offender registry, he emphasized that “every option is on the table” moving forward. For many years, various individuals and groups have requested a third-party database of offenders within SBC churches.

Oklahoma pastor Wade Burleson has called for a database since 2007, saying it’s a “moral obligation.” After Greear’s address Monday, Burleson tweeted:

Thom Rainer, CEO of LifeWay Resources, the SBC’s publishing arm, also supports a registry. “We’ve definitely had people advocating it up to this point,” he tells the HC, “but (support) has never been at the crescendo that it is now.”

Previous article8 Signs Your Church Is Actually Reaching Unchurched People
Next articleThe Children of Catholic Priests Just Want to Be Acknowledged
Stephanie Martin
Stephanie Martin, a freelance journalist, has worked in Christian publishing for 26 years. She’s active at her church in Lakewood, Colorado, where she lives with her husband and two teenage daughters.

Get the ChurchLeaders Daily Sent to Your Inbox