Home Blog Page 444

97-Yr-Old Grandpa Sings ‘How Great Thou Art’ to Jesus Just Before Going to Heaven

grandpa sings
Screengrab via YouTube / @rumbleviral

The bittersweet moment when a loved one slips from this world into eternity is a poignant reminder of our mortality and the vastness of our God. It’s a moment, if only fleeting, that assures us our lives are but a vapor and heaven is home. If you knew it was your last day on earth, would you spend it singing praises to the King? That’s exactly what this sweet 97-year-old grandpa sings in a video that is tugging on heartstrings across the Internet.

“I was blessed to capture a video of my 97-year-old grandpa, as he sang: ‘How Great Thou Art’ from his hospital bed, with dear friends and family,” one of his grandchildren wrote on Facebook: “The next morning, he went to be with Jesus.”

Watch this beautiful bedside worship service unfold in the video below:

97-Yr-Old Grandpa Sings ‘How Great Thou Art’

This article originally appeared on FaithIt. Check out other inspiring stories there. FaithIt.com is a website designed to drive social sharing of faith-based and inspirational stories. The site made its mark as one of the fastest-growing websites on the Internet and continues to reach influencers in the home every day with engaging, cause-driven content.

5 Keys to Winning People Over

teen pregnancy

The toughest thing about fresh insight, new strategies and a personal passion to make something happen is the wait for others to catch on. Am I right!? Here are five things to help you stay the course in winning people over when you pitch a project, champion a strategy and win people over to lead change of any kind.

5 Keys to Winning People Over

1. It’s a trip, not a destination.

If we’re focused on the outcome, we’ll constantly feel the frustration instead of the win. But, if we focus on the people over the project (or the process over the event) relationships will gradually strengthen and each little step will feel like a win on the way to our ultimate goal. Remember, it’s less about technique than it is attitude. Celebrate the first downs along the way to the end zone.

2. It’s not “all or nothing.”

We can’t change everyone and everything all at once. There are going to be several steps forward and a couple steps back along the way. Don’t let that discourage you. It’s like a golf game. You’re going to have some good rounds and some bad ones. When you have a bad round, pick up your gear and move on to the next hole. A bad swing or lost ball never means it’s time to walk off the course.

3. It’s not a single transaction.

Rarely, if ever, is a one-size-fits-all roll-out effective. Some groups require more time than others and what works for one person won’t work with the next. Build in time to navigate through different personalities to discover what motivates and builds trust for each person and group. Pick one or two to invest in first to build trust and create some key, visible wins. It will attract others to the cause and you’ll gradually gain momentum and speed. Along the way, build ongoing checkpoints into the process to keep processing the wins, the struggles and the cost of standing still.

Kids Leading the Way: 6 Thoughts on Children Serving as Leaders

teen pregnancy

Are kids leading the way in your children’s ministry program? Do you let children take leadership roles at church? It’s time we start giving kids more opportunities to lead.

Throughout Scripture, kids had opportunities to lead. Here’s an example in Matthew 21:

... and the teachers of the law saw the wonderful things He did and the children shouting in the temple courts, “Hosanna to the Son of David,” they were indignant. “Do you hear what these children are saying?” they asked him. “Yes,” replied Jesus, “have you never read, “‘From the lips of children and infants you, Lord, have called forth your praise’?”

Jesus was all for kids leading the way in the Temple that day. And I believe He is also for kids leading the way today.

6 Thoughts on Kids Leading the Way

1. There is no “Jr. Holy Spirit.”

The Spirit of God can lead and control kids and adults alike. Throughout Scripture, God uses children young people. The boy giving his lunch to Jesus. David defeating Goliath. The maid helping Naaman get healed. As we just read, children leading the way to praise Jesus in the temple.

2. Kids have a heart to serve. 

Have you ever asked a group of kids who’d like to help with something? Hands shoot up everywhere. Kids naturally have a heart to help others. It is when they get older, that they stop raising their hand as often.

Why? In some cases, children are told they’re too young. They’re told they don’t have the abilities needed. That they should sit still and be quiet. That they have to wait until they are a certain age. This type of treatment causes kids to eventually stop raising their hand and saying “no” to serving as adults.

3.  Kids will act like kids.  

Kids are wired to move. They are full of energy. Don’t expect them to turn it off when it’s time to serve. This may mean putting them in a role that allows them to use their energy. It might be helping with worship so they can jump around. It might be helping lead a fun, energetic game or activity. Instead of squelching kids, help them grow and flourish with the gifts God gives them.

Former Megachurch Elder Arrested for Torture, Murder of Adoptive Daughter

rock church
Image credit: (L) Google Maps, (R) sdsheriff.gov

A former elder at San Diego’s Rock Church—a megachurch founded by former NFL player Miles McPhersonhas been arrested and charged with the murder and torture of her 11-year-old adoptive daughter. Leticia McCormack and her parents, Stanley and Adella Tom, were arrested on Nov. 7 in connection with the death of Arabella McCormack. 

“I pray Leticia and her parents rot in that prison,” said Torriana Florey, Arabella’s biological mother, at the arraignment. “I want everything thrown at them, the book, everything.” 

Rock Church Elder Arrested for Murder, Torture 

On Aug. 30, sheriff’s deputies responded to a 2 a.m. “call of a child in distress” at a home on Lakeview Drive in Spring Valley. “The child, Arabella McCormack, was rushed to a hospital,” said the San Diego County Sheriff’s Department in a press release. “During the investigation, detectives suspected signs of possible child abuse. While in the hospital, Arabella’s health declined and she died.” Lt. Chris Steffen told The San Diego Union-Tribune that the girl’s body showed signs of bruising and “severe levels of malnourishment.”

“The Sheriff’s Homicide Unit responded and assumed responsibility of the investigation,” the release continues. “During the investigation into Arabella’s death, deputies contacted her father, Brian McCormack, near the family’s home. He committed suicide in their presence.” 

Brian and Leticia McCormack began fostering Arabella and her two sisters (ages 6 and 7) in 2017 and adopted them in 2019. NBC 7 reports that the two younger girls were removed from the McCormack home at the time of Arabella’s death, hospitalized for several days, and are currently living with a foster family. 

All three defendants have been charged with torture and willful cruelty to a child. Leticia McCormack and Stanley Tom have also both been charged with murder. The defendants face life in prison if convicted on all charges. They have pled not guilty and will appear in court next on Nov. 16.

According to Rock Church’s website, former NFL player and senior pastor Miles McPherson started Rock Church in 2000, and the church now has five campuses and an attendance of over 18,000. Leticia McCormack was a volunteer and ordained elder at Rock Church. Some outlets have reported that McCormack served in leadership at the Rock School of Ministry, but that her profile has since been removed

Rock Church says it has cut ties with Leticia McCormack and is revoking her ordination. In a statement to ChurchLeaders, the church said:

We have received notice that Leticia and her parents have been arrested as a result of the Sheriff’s Department investigation. We continue to grieve for Arabella and her sisters. We are so sorry that their family and friends are experiencing this unimaginable loss and pain. We send our deepest condolences to all that are grieving at this time. Our hearts go out to each of them.  

The legal process will run its course and we hope justice for Arabella and her sisters will be served. We are praying that God’s love and grace will bring comfort and healing. 

The Rock no longer has any official relationship with Leticia. Her ordination at Rock Church was previously suspended and is in the process of being revoked.

Regard Leticia McCormak’s specific role at Rock Church, the church issued the following statement:

Leticia McCormack began volunteering with the Rock Church in 2013 and has helped in various capacities, including administrative tasks and helping coordinate events and other ministry activities.

Former RZIM Leaders ‘Not Fit To Be in Ministry,’ Says Team of Apologists

RZIM
Ravi Zacharias. Screenshot from YouTube / @Apologetics - Jude 1:3

After investigating the leadership culture at Ravi Zacharias International Ministries (RZIM), a team of Christian apologists has concluded that three former leaders of the now-defunct organization are “not fit to be in ministry or leadership positions.” As a result, the apologists say they won’t partner with or endorse the work of Sarah (Davis) Phillips, Michael Ramsden, or Abdu Murray “until the fruit consistent with genuine repentance is evident in their lives.”

On November 9, the apologists published a summary of findings at RisenJesus.com, detailing numerous “types of abuse and deception that were representative of RZIM’s organizational culture.” Included on the team are Paul Copan, William Lane Craig, Debbie Licona, Michael Licona, and Sean McDowell. (All but Debbie Licona hold doctorate degrees.)

Michael Licona, the report’s author, notes that because “no apologetics governing body exists…we believe that we had both a spiritual and moral obligation to set up a committee to make an inquiry and follow the evidence wherever it led.”

The investigators conducted more than 1,000 hours of research, including interviews with 25 people and consultations with abuse experts. The new report follows years of scandal, lawsuits, and fallout from sexual abuse allegations against Ravi Zacharias. After the renowned apologist and author died in May 2020 at age 74, several independent reports indicated “significant, credible evidence” of wrongdoing by him.

Church Leaders has reported extensively about the allegations and reports, as well as continued insistence by Zacharias’ family members that he’s innocent.

RZIM Leaders Intimidated Staffers Who Raised Concerns, Says Report

In their summary, the apologists list 18 conclusions. The first is that RZIM’s Senior Leadership Team (SLT)—consisting of Phillips, Ramsden, and Murray—“intimidated, mistreated, or retaliated against” RZIM staff members who “pushed back or asked legitimate questions” from 2017 to 2021.

“Those employees were doing what the SLT had a responsibility to do and failed to do,” notes the report. It adds that despite the “morally necessary” actions of concerned employees, SLT members maintained that those employees were wrong and intended to “bring the ministry down.” Moreover, Phillips, Ramsden, and Murray portrayed themselves as “victims” and led some people outside of RZIM to “believe the worst about the employees who have raised public concerns.”

Investigators “heard testimony and received documentation stating that SLT members chastised employees for asking questions.” Although the investigators “cannot prove that anyone was terminated for pushing back and asking questions, the environment at RZIM was such that this would have been a reasonable inference.”

The report describes a spiritually and emotionally abusive conciliation process that the SLT allegedly used to control internal “errant troublemakers.” Leaders brought in Judy Dabler to be an “enforcer,” states the report, but the process amounted to “psychological torture.”

Pastor Made Famous for Livestreamed Robbery Seeking $50 Million in Defamation Suit Against NY Radio Station

Lamor Whitehead
Screengrab via Instagram @iambishopwhitehead

The ever stylish and seldom reserved Brooklyn pastor Bishop Lamor Whitehead is again making headlines, this time for suing a New York area radio station for defamation. Whitehead is seeking damages in the amount of $50 million. 

Whitehead first became a household name in July when he was robbed at gunpoint of roughly $1 million in jewelry while delivering a sermon at Leaders of Tomorrow International Ministries, where he serves as pastor. The robbery was caught on the church’s livestream. 

Following the robbery, Whitehead became a vocal supporter of legislation that would enable pastors and clergy to carry firearms, regardless of criminal history. Whitehead himself has such a history, having previously served a prison sentence for grand larceny and identity theft. 

“I’m calling on every elected official that has power to protect houses of worship,” Whitehead said during a press conference held outside his church in August. “We need protection. We need you to sympathize with us. We don’t get the luxury of having firearms. All we’re asking is help us protect ourselves. Pass a law where we can carry our firearms, because this gun violence has gone to a new level.”

Also following the robbery, Whitehead became the subject of scrutiny and criticism, both for the gaudy nature of his clothing, jewelry, and car, as well as for litigation against him alleging that he plundered $90,000 from a congregant’s retirement fund. 

Whitehead publicly denied that the accusations of theft are true, referring to the allegations as “hype,” and characterizing his accusers as seeking to take advantage of his financial success.

Whitehead has repeatedly defended his lavish lifestyle, arguing that criticism against him on the grounds of his wealth is racially motivated.

“I don’t see y’all talking about Joel Osteen,” Whitehead has said.

Additionally, Whitehead has become involved in several personal disputes since the robbery. This has included an incident wherein Whitehead was briefly detained by police following a physical altercation with a woman disrupting his sermon at Leaders of Tomorrow, a heated and profanity-laced verbal altercation with Christian content creator and pastor Larry Reid (which was broadcasted live on Reid’s Instagram), and a public dispute with Comedian D.L. Hughley, wherein Whitehead invited Hughley to a boxing max, promising to knock Hughley out “in the name of Jesus.”

Whitehead has now filed litigation against 94.7 The Block, its parent company Paramount, and radio host Tarsha Jones, whom Whitehead is alleging defamed him on the radio. 

“On or about 9/13/2022, Miss Jones, on her morning radio show on 94.7 The Block, said that Bishop Whitehead: is a ‘drug dealer,’ ‘using the church to hide that old drug money;’ ‘assaulted the young lady,’ and ‘[his] church is where he’s probably still doing his dirty work,’” the complaint says, referring to an accusation that Whitehead uses his church to launder drug money. 

Steven Curtis Chapman: Life Without Jesus ‘Leads to Hopelessness and Utter Darkness’

Steven Curtis Chapman
Steven Curtis Chapman at 53rd GMA Dove Awards. Photo by Isaac Pittman

Five-time Grammy Award-winning Christian artist Steven Curtis Chapman is no stranger to the Gospel Music Association’s Dove Awards. Chapman has received 59 Dove Awards, seven of them being the “Artist of the Year” award, a feat that no other artist has accomplished. Further, he isn’t planning on slowing down anytime soon.

In fact, the 59-year-old Christian music icon released a new album this past October titled “Still” and in October performed at the 53rd Annual Dove Awards.

ChurchLeaders caught up with the “Great Adventure” singer on the Dove Awards’ red carpet ask him what inspires him, as well as how he has been able to sustain success across so many years.

RELATED: At Dove Awards TobyMac Talks Son’s Death, Collaborating With Sheryl Crow, and How a Youth Pastor Changed His Life

“I still am compelled to write and create art that’s illuminated by my faith,” Chapman said. The veteran Christian music artist explained that he sets out to make the best art he can, because people who know the art giver, God, ought to be making the best music out there.

“God continues this beautiful thing about the journey of faith. You know, we never arrive until finally the Father says, ‘Come home,’” which means, Chapman said, we continue to learn and grow.

The musician shared that, in the past few years, his heart has been broken in ways it never has before, inspiring the song on his latest album “Still.“

“Not only personally in my family—14 years ago losing our daughter,” he said, “but then this pandemic sorta brought a lot of that back to the surface, some of the scabs of loss and and grief for us, because we were touched by it with our family and friends and world. And while it isolated us, it also, in so many ways, stirred so much in my heart and I just started writing songs about it. That’s the way I process and the way I wrestle through things is with music.”

Chapman has released over 20 albums throughout his career, including his album “First Hand,” which debuted over 35 years ago. He expressed that he doesn’t plan on stopping until Jesus takes him home to heaven, saying, “I feel like as long as I’m breathing, I’m probably going to still be writing songs, because that’s going to be how I’m still trying to process out what’s happening in here, what’s happening around me.”

RELATED: Brooklyn Pastor Robbed During Livestream Sends a Message to Churches at Dove Awards Red Carpet

Having experienced various trials and accomplishing more than most Christian artists ever do, Chapman encouraged Christians to seek Jesus, because life apart from him will lead hopelessness and utter darkness.

“I have more questions—far more questions than answers now, with life and all that we’ve lived through and gone through,” Chapman said. “[Christians] know how the story ends. So let’s keep reminding each other and encouraging each other because there’s nowhere else to turn that isn’t just complete and utter hopelessness.”

Correction: A previous version of this article said that “Still” was released in August.

Religion Plays a Role in Native American Adoption Case Before Supreme Court

Indian Child Welfare Act
The U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington, June 27, 2022. (AP Photo/Patrick Semansky, File)

(RNS) — As the Supreme Court hears the case of Brackeen v. Haaland on Wednesday (Nov. 9), what is at stake for most interested parties is the decades-old Indian Child Welfare Act, considered by many to be the “gold standard” of child welfare policy. Passed by Congress in 1978, the act was meant to stop Native American families from being separated by state child welfare agencies and private adoption services and instead seek placement for children within a federally recognized tribe.

But some also see Brackeen v. Haaland as case about religious liberty, and not only because at its heart is, as The New York Times put it earlier this week, “the Solomonic fight over the fate of a child.”

“This absolutely is about culture/religion,” Robert Miller, a professor of law at the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at Arizona State University, told Religion News Service.

“It’s about raising your citizens for the future to preserve your language, your cultural practices. You and I could easily put the category of religion on that,” said Miller, an enrolled citizen of the Eastern Shawnee Tribe and tribal judge.

RELATED: Before a month celebrating adoption, a day to recognize adoptees’ trauma

The plaintiffs in the Supreme Court case, Jennifer and Chad Brackeen, are a white couple living in Texas who want to adopt a now 4-year-old girl whose birth mother is Navajo. The couple had already adopted the girl’s brother, who shares the same birth mother, and when the girl was born in 2018 and fostered by another family, the couple filed for custody of her, too.

But ICWA establishes that children in foster care who are eligible for tribal membership should be placed with extended family, another member of their tribe or another Native American family whenever possible. And a relative — a great-aunt who lives in the Navajo Nation in Arizona and visits regularly with the children’s older siblings — also wants to adopt the girl.

In 2017, the Brackeens became the lead plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit brought by the state attorneys general of Texas, Louisiana and Indiana and other families challenging the law.

In 2019, a Texas judge ruled that the two families would share custody, with the girl living primarily with the Brackeens and spending time each summer with her great-aunt in the Navajo Nation.

The Brackeens’ case argues the Indian Child Welfare Act is unconstitutional, explained Ana Eveleigh, a Barnard College student who worked with Columbia Law School’s Law, Rights, and Religion Project this summer to analyze the religious dynamics in Brackeen v. Haaland. The argument lies in part in the idea that the law constitutes racial discrimination by determining the placement of children based on race, Eveleigh said.

Californians Overwhelmingly Support Abortion Rights Over Catholic Bishops’ Objections

California Gov. Gavin Newsom, right, takes selfies with supporters at a rally in support of Proposition 1 at Long Beach City College in Long Beach, California, Nov. 6, 2022. (AP Photo/Damian Dovarganes)

LOS ANGELES (RNS) — California will codify the right to abortion in the state’s constitution after voters on Tuesday (Nov. 8) overwhelmingly approved a measure that Catholic bishops and other Christian leaders rallied against and prayed for its defeat.

With the passage of Proposition 1, the California Constitution will declare that the state “shall not deny or interfere with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions, which includes their fundamental right to choose to have an abortion and their fundamental right to choose or refuse contraceptives.”

Early Wednesday results showed 69% of voters approved the measure.

As Election Day approached, Los Angeles Archbishop José H. Gomez led Catholic bishops across the state in urging residents to vote against the measure, which was placed on the ballot soon after the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision this summer to overturn Roe v. Wade. Critics, who also included conservative Protestant faith leaders, alleged that Proposition 1 “would remove all restrictions on abortion in California” and allow abortions up to the moment of birth.

The amendment does not spell out which, if any, types of abortions would still be prohibited. State law already restricts third-trimester abortions, and California legal experts have said they don’t expect courts to interpret the amendment as expressly permitting them.

RELATED: Newsom Launches ‘Biblical’ Pro-Abortion Billboard in Pro-Life States; ‘This Is Nothing Short of Demonic,” Feucht Says

Ballot measures supporting abortion rights were also approved by voters in Vermont and Michigan, which in both places made both abortion and contraception a right. In Kentucky, a proposed amendment declaring that no right to abortion exists went down to defeat, though abortion is banned by law in the state.

California’s decision represents a second disappointment for American Catholic bishops, who took a strong stand supporting a proposed “no right to abortion” amendment in Kansas in August, only to see voters turn it back.

In a video shared Monday, Bishop Alberto Rojas of the Diocese of San Bernardino said the measure “promotes a culture of death” and “doesn’t affirm the beauty and value of a life that God has given us.”

Bishop Oscar Cantú of San Jose, Bishop Kevin W. Vann of Orange, and Auxiliary Bishop Timothy Freyer of Orange published a column Friday in America, a Jesuit magazine, in which they referred to Proposition 1 as “extreme” and “unnecessary.”

“California already has some of the most permissive abortion laws in the country,” they wrote, adding that it would pave the way for “some of the most permissive abortion policies in the world.”

The California Family Council, a nonprofit aiming to advance “God’s design for life, family and liberty,” led a vigil Tuesday on the steps of the state Capitol. Pastors Jed Dahlen of Calvary Solid Ground, Joe Pedick of Calvary Chapel of the Harbour and John Randall of Calvary South OC were among faith leaders who prayed for the defeat of the measure.

This article originally appeared here.

Pro-Life Efforts on Ballot Initiatives Fail in at Least 4 States

Photo via Unsplash.com @Tessa Rampersad

NASHVILLE (BP) – Pro-life advocates appeared poised to suffer across-the-board losses on five state ballot initiatives voted on Tuesday (Nov. 8) in the first nationwide election since the reversal of the Roe v. Wade decision.

The failure to gain passage of a pro-life measure in Kentucky or to defeat constitutional amendments that guarantee abortion rights in California, Michigan and Vermont dealt a troubling setback to Southern Baptists and other Americans who welcomed the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling in June. In addition, the vote totals reported in Montana by midday Wednesday (Nov. 9) seemed to indicate a pro-life proposal would fall short of passage.

By overturning Roe, the high court had returned regulation of abortion to the states and brought an end to a legal regime throughout the country that resulted in the deaths of an estimated 63 million-plus preborn children since 1973.

Abortion-rights advocates have now prevailed in at least five state initiatives since Roe fell. In August, Kansas voters defeated an amendment that would have affirmed that the state constitution does not protect the right to abortion or require public funding of abortion.

RELATED: Newsom Launches ‘Biblical’ Pro-Abortion Billboard in Pro-Life States; ‘This Is Nothing Short of Demonic,” Feucht Says

Southern Baptist leaders called Wednesday for perseverance in the pro-life cause.

“As a 52-year-old pastor, I recognize that the generation ahead of me fought for 50 years before they saw the reversal of the unconstitutional Roe v. Wade decision,” SBC President Bart Barber told Baptist Press in written comments. “I pray that my generation and the pro-life generations after me will apply the same steadfast diligence to the cause of ending abortion state by state.

“May we not be dissuaded by temporary setbacks,” he said. “May we continue to act in wisdom and truth to defend the lives of babies, each of whom deserves to live.”

Brent Leatherwood, president of the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, told BP the results on these state initiatives, “while not unexpected in some contexts, are disappointing nonetheless.”

“But it confirms something we have said all along: The end of Roe did not mean the end of the pro-life movement but, instead, the beginning of a new chapter where our message of life and serving mothers is going to be taken door to door and neighborhood to neighborhood,” Leatherwood said.

“So we now look to redouble our efforts advocating for the vulnerable and, as one pastor told me just this morning, roll our sleeves up to make abortion unthinkable so we can get to a place where it is illegal.”

In Kentucky, voters defeated a constitutional amendment similar to the one that failed in Kansas. As of 12:30 CST Wednesday (Nov. 9), Amendment 2 trailed by 52-48 percent with an estimated 90 percent of votes counted, according to a report by The New York Times using results from The Associated Press. Kentucky law currently prohibits abortion except to protect the mother’s life or to avert “the serious, permanent impairment of a life-sustaining organ” in the mother.

“We are disappointed in the defeat of Amendment 2,” said Todd Gray, executive director of the Kentucky Baptist Convention. “Legalized abortion is the greatest human rights atrocity of our day, and Kentucky Baptists will continue to work and pray that it remains illegal in our state.

RELATED: Dove Award-Winning Artist Canceled by MLB Partner League Team Because of Pro-Life Stance

“We are grateful to have an attorney general [Daniel Cameron] who will fight to uphold Kentucky’s pro-life laws in court,” Gray said in a written statement, “and we ask our state legislators to renew their commitment to passing legislation that protects unborn children made in the image of God.”

California, already entrenched as the country’s No. 1 abortion-providing state, approved the Right to Reproductive Freedom Act. By a 65-35 percent margin with an estimated 42 percent of votes reporting, Californians chose to amend their constitution to bar the state from denying or interfering “with an individual’s reproductive freedom in their most intimate decisions,” including the right to have an abortion.

Jonathan Keller, president of the California Family Council (CFC), decried the result.

“Yesterday’s election was disastrous for California,” he told BP in written comments. CFC is a partner with the California Southern Baptist Convention. “Voters overwhelmingly approved one of the most extreme abortion laws in the entire world.

Ex-Vatican Auditor, Threatening To Reveal All, Sues Church, Alleging Damage to His Reputation

Libero Milone
A view of St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican, Nov. 10, 2020. (AP Photo/Andrew Medichini, File)

VATICAN CITY (RNS) — Former Vatican financial auditor Libero Milone filed suit on Friday (Nov. 4) against the Vatican Secretariat of State, demanding the Catholic Church pay for damages to his reputation that he alleges followed his unceremonious firing in 2017.

At a meeting on Tuesday (Nov. 8) arranged by his lawyer, Milone told reporters that Cardinal Angelo Becciu, once the third-highest-ranking official at the Vatican, was “the mastermind of the so-called operation eject-Milone.”

Milone was hired in 2015 by Pope Francis to look into the notoriously convoluted and troubled finances of Vatican departments as part of continuing financial reforms begun by Pope Benedict XVI. Only two years later, the Vatican announced that Milone had resigned in the face of accusations of embezzlement and of spying.

As Milone was ushered out, Becciu told reporters that the auditor “went against all rules and was spying on the private lives of his superiors and staff, myself included.” Milone shot back, calling the cardinal “a liar.”

According to Milone, prosecutors have now relaunched an investigation into his tenure at the Vatican, as well as his deputy’s. Milone has been called for questioning at the Vatican on Monday.

The Vatican did not respond to repeated requests for comment.

On Tuesday, the former auditor framed his firing as a battle between “the Middle Ages and modernity” and called out “the small mafia at the Vatican” that was offended by his findings of lapses in the Catholic institution’s finances, including “many cases of rule violations, improper predisposition of accounting records, incorrect registrations.”

Milone said he is ready to share proof of the financial mismanagement he said he witnessed at Vatican-owned hospitals and in the church bureaucracy. He and his deputy, Ferruccio Panicco, are asking the Secretariat to pay nearly 10 million euros for reputational and mental damages.

Panicco, who was fired at the same time as Milone, claims the Vatican withheld his personal data after his firing as it investigated him, causing him to lose precious time in his fight against prostate cancer. “I think they are guilty of sentencing me to death for no reason, after slow and significant suffering,” he told reporters Tuesday, reading from a written statement.

Vatican documents viewed by Religion News Service show that Vatican police claimed to have investigated the auditor and his deputy for seven months and found evidence of “illicit conduct,” which led to a judicial proceeding against them for espionage and embezzlement. But in a letter dated May 19, 2018, the Vatican’s top prosecutor wrote that there were no criminal charges against Milone.

Milone said he has sent seven letters to the pope and has received no reply. The former auditor said he has maintained a dialogue with Secretary of State Pietro Parolin, but church officials have refused to settle his case.

Prosecutors at the Vatican are currently grappling with a massive financial trial of 10 Vatican employees and curial members, including Becciu, who are charged with, among other things, abuse of power, embezzlement and witness tampering in connection with the controversial 2014 purchase of London real estate made using a papal fund earmarked for charity.

Religious Freedom Dismissed in Nevada, Arkansas; Legal Marijuana Results Vary

Photo via Unsplash.com @bdots_fam

CARSON CITY, Nev. (BP) – Voters in Nevada and Arkansas took steps deemed contrary to and problematic for religious freedom in Nov. 8 midterm elections, while legalized marijuana passed in two of the five states that considered it.

Nevada voters added gender identity and sexual orientation to freedoms protected in the state constitution with 57.11 percent of voters approving the Equality of Rights Amendment, Nevada Secretary of State Barbara Cegavske reported.

Arkansans appeared to have narrowly defeated a constitutional amendment that would have restricted the government from burdening religious freedom “even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability,” and limiting such actions to “the least restrictive means.” With 97.3 percent of the vote counted, Issue Number 3 or the Arkansas Religious Freedom Amendment was failing with 50.44 percent of voters opposing it, Arkansas Secretary of State John Thurston reported.

Among states that sought to legalize marijuana use, Maryland and Missouri approved the measure, while it failed in Arkansas, North Dakota and South Dakota.

RELATED: John MacArthur Calls Religious Freedom ‘Nonsense’: ‘We Support the Truth’

The Nevada constitutional amendment, opposed by religious liberty advocates including the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), adds gender identity or expression and sexual orientation to a long list of protected rights including race, color, creed, sex, age, disability, ancestry and national origin.

The amendment opens the door to “government-mandated discrimination, inequality and coercion,” ADF has said of the measure, saying men who self-identify as women would be allowed to compete for spots on female sports teams, women’s scholarships and other opportunities specifically designated for women.

In Arkansas, the state sought to add a measure to the constitution that would provide freedoms enacted in the U.S. Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA) of 1993 but were not applicable to states. At least 21 states have approved such measures since the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in 1997 that the RFRA did not apply to states, according to Ballotpedia.org.

J.D. “Sonny” Tucker, executive director of the Arkansas Baptist Convention, hailed the measure as “a great prescription to ensure the health of our society.”

“If passed, the amendment would elevate the language to the state constitution and help protect religious freedom for future generations from the whims and preferences of future elections or politics,” he told Baptist Press in advance of the vote. “It is my sincere hope that the voters of Arkansas value strong protection of religious freedom enough to pass Issue 3.”

Efforts to legalize adult use and possession of marijuana passed in Maryland with 65.54 percent of the vote, and in Missouri with 53.11 percent of the vote, according to unofficial election results from the respective secretaries of state.

RELATED: Boston Pays Out $2.1M To Settle Christian Flag Legal Case

The Missouri measure applies to adults over the age of 21, enacts a 6 percent tax on the retail price of recreational marijuana and allows persons convicted of certain marijuana-related offenses to petition for release from prison and have their records expunged, according to the measure.

Maryland’s law makes marijuana use legal for adults beginning in July 2023 and directs the Maryland legislature to pass laws for the use, distribution, regulation and taxation of the substance.

Your Kids Will Get Your Attention—The Question Is How

attention
Adobestock #480348867

Kids today are facing an attention dilemma. They crave attention from their parents and leaders, and they will often get it one way or another through various means. This could mean seeking attention in the right ways or demanding it in the wrong ways.

Jesus knew how to deal with children and their need for attention. He set a great example for us to follow: “And he took them up into his arms, put his hands upon them, and blessed them.” (Mark 10:16)

Here are some ways your kids will get your attention.

Positive Attention or Negative Attention

Kids are created not only with a need but with a craving for attention. Because it’s not just the attention, but love, they are seeking. And in the mind of a child, love is spelled time.

As they age, if they’re not given the right kinds of attention, they are more likely to seek out the wrong kinds of attention, or in the wrong kinds of ways.

Instead of showing love to get attention, they often demonstrate misbehavior. Instead of following rules, they may intentionally disobey them because it gets them the attention they are craving, even if it’s negative attention.

The most precious gift you can give someone is the gift of your time and attention. (Nicky Gumbel)

Family Attention or Friend Attention

The majority of a child’s primary attention needs often can and should be met through the home. While attention from peers can be both natural and healthy, it can also become dangerous if a child is seeking approval and attention from outside of the home to make up for not having received it inside the home.

We see this at times when children are accepted by wrong friend groups or even willing to do clearly wrong things in order to fill an attention need that has gone unmet at home.

You should never take responsibility for more children than you can give attention to. (James Redfield)

Attention Now or Attention Later

Parents who give their kids quality, positive attention when they are young prevent their children from tendencies to act out or misbehave in order to seek needed attention when they’re older.

Children who grow up with a healthy diet of praise and positive attention from their parents are much less likely to deal with issues of low self-esteem or anxiety as they enter adulthood.

It’s easier to build strong children than to repair broken men. (Frederick Douglass)

A daughter will be less likely to seek out wrong male attention as a teen if she is receiving positive male attention from her father throughout her childhood. A son who has been made to feel confident in himself will be much less likely to seek or need to prove his manliness through unhealthy or toxic means.

Behind every child who believes in himself is a parent who believed in them first.

In what right or wrong ways are your children seeking attention? How could you give them the best of your time and attention this week?

This article originally appeared here and is used by permission. 

14 Things I Seldom Hear in Church

teen pregnancy

Many of us could write blog posts about surprising things we’ve heard in church. Here, though, are 14 things I’ve seldom heard in church in my 40+ years as a believer:

  1. “I planned to fall morally.” I’ve never met anybody who set out to fall into sin. I have, though, known people who fell.
  2. “Looking back, I really regret serving God.” I’ve never heard those words from someone who truly gave his or her life to God.
  3. “I got married with the intent of getting divorced.” Nobody I know has walked the marriage aisle assuming he or she would someday end the marriage. I do know many, however, who still got divorced.
  4. “I love singing songs I don’t know.” Regardless of one’s preferred worship style, I’ve not met many people who enjoy singing new hymns or choruses. Most of us prefer to worship with familiarity.
  5. “We love you enough to remove you from membership.” I’ve heard this one occasionally, but likely not enough if congregations are truly being New Testament churches.
  6. “We can start small group early since everyone’s here on time.” It’s funny, you know – churches are often deeply concerned about ending on time, but they don’t worry much about starting on time.
  7. “I don’t mind it when your boring preaching is also long.” I’m sure you hear two points here. I’ve never heard anyone appreciate boring preaching, and I’ve certainly never heard anyone affirm long boring preaching.
  8. “I hope we send out more people than we keep here.” Some younger leaders are beginning to speak this language, but not many.
  9. “I want my pastor to speak more about money.” If anyone says this, it’s usually the church treasurer….
  10. “I’m praying that the Lord will call my children and grandchildren to the mission field.” It’s one thing to dedicate a baby to the Lord when he’s in your arms; it’s another matter to let him go when he’s grown up.
  11. “To free up room for guests, I’ll sit on the front row.” Many people would rather stand than sit in the front.
  12. “I pray regularly that the enemy will not win in the lives of our pastors.” Too many church members recognize the reality of spiritual warfare in their pastors’ lives only after a pastor has fallen.
  13. “I grieve when we don’t see people saved through our church’s ministry.” We may rejoice when people do get saved, but we don’t match our rejoicing with grief when nobody’s getting saved.
  14. “I really don’t like baptisms.” I don’t know anybody who doesn’t get excited (even a little) when a new believer illustrates his or her faith by baptism.

What would you add to this list?

This article about things you’ll seldom hear in church originally appeared here, and is used by permission.

Brian Houston Says He Is ‘Encouraged,’ Despite It Being ‘A H*** of a Year’

Brian Houston
Composite image. Screenshot from Facebook / @Brian Houston

Brian Houston says that he and his wife, Bobbie, expect to spend “at least another decade” in ministry, despite the recent challenges they have faced. The former pastor of Hillsong Church expressed these thoughts at an event he and his wife, Bobbie, held Wednesday in Sydney, Australia, called, “An Evening with Bobbie and Brian.”

“I had it in my heart to just have a meeting where we get the chance to connect with a lot of friends,” said Brian Houston, “a lot of people who we’ve done a lot of life with and, of course, some faces we don’t know so well as well, and it’s already been good for our souls.”

Bobbie and Brian Houston Look to the Future

Originally planned as one session on the evening of Wednesday, Nov. 9, “An Evening with Bobbie and Brian” will actually take place over two evenings. Due to the level of demand, the Houstons added a second session Wednesday evening and then a third that will take place the evening of Thursday, Nov. 10. Wednesday’s 7:30 p.m. session was live streamed. 

“An Evening with Bobbie and Brian” took place at the Pioneer Theatre in Castle Hill (a suburb of Sydney) and featured prayer, worship, and messages from Brian and Bobbie Houston, respectively. Brian told those in attendance that he and Bobbie have been praying about their plans in 2023, but that they will not give those plans serious attention until they are through 2022. 

The pastor expressed hopefulness about the future and asked people to pray for him and Bobbie to hear from the Holy Spirit as they consider their next steps. The couple expects “at least another decade of productive ministry, fruitful ministry, whatever that looks like.”

“I feel encouraged, believe it or not,” said Brian. “It’s been a h*** of a year.” 

Brian Houston is scheduled to appear in court on Dec. 2 to face charges that he concealed child sex offenses committed by his father, Frank Houston, in the 1970s. The case is set to run for three weeks, and Brian Houston has denied that the charges are true. 

The New South Wales (NSW) Police Force charged Brian Houston on Aug. 5, 2021, and the following month, he announced that he had stepped aside from Hillsong Church boards. In January 2022, the pastor announced that he would be stepping aside from leadership at Hillsong for all of 2022 in order to focus on the court proceedings.

In March, the Hillsong Global Board revealed that Brian’s sabbatical was related to the pastor’s past inappropriate behavior toward two women, as well as substance abuse. Days after this news broke, Hillsong announced that Brian Houston had resigned as global senior pastor. 

Franklin Graham on the Election Results: ‘Our Country Can’t Turn Its Back on God and Expect His Hand of Blessing To Continue’

Franklin Graham
Matt Johnson from Omaha, Nebraska, United States, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Franklin Graham, president and CEO of Samaritan’s Purse and the Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, posted a comment regarding the results of Tuesday’s (Nov. 8) midterm elections.

Franklin Graham on the 2022 Midterms

Graham posted a quote from his father, Billy Graham, the morning of yesterday’s election that said, “Ask God to guide you as you vote—and then make the effort to get to the polls during this election. And once the election is over, pray for those who have been elected, that they may seek God’s will for our nation—and do it.”

Like his father before him, Graham is friends with many conservative politicians and isn’t afraid to speak out on political issues that affect the nation and the church.

RELATED: ‘We Would Be Facing an Armageddon’—Franklin Graham Urges Christians To Pray After Putin Threatens To Use Nuclear Weapons

Almost 24 hours later, Franklin Graham offered some timely wisdom for Christians who follow him on social media. “Some people may be sad, some may be glad, and some may be mad about the election results. One thing’s for sure—our success as a nation depends on God,” Graham said.

“Our country can’t turn its back on God and expect His hand of blessing to continue,” Graham warned. “We need His help, protection, and favor. Whether or not you agree with the candidates who just won, we are to pray for them. The only hope for America is God.”

How Other Christian Leaders Reacted to the Election Results

Many other conservative Christian leaders have posted their opinions regarding yesterday’s election results. While the tallies of votes haven’t gone in many conservatives’ favor, a lot of Christian leaders have encouraged Christians to remember that their hope doesn’t come from political results, but in Jesus Christ alone. Here is what a few posted on their social media accounts.

Grace To You’s Darrel Harrison shared that he is glad the predicted Republican “red wave” didn’t come true, “Speaking for myself,” Harrison posted, “as a Christian conservative, I’m happy the Republican ‘red wave’ did not materialize. I say that because politics is too often viewed as a means of redeeming the culture, when the reality is the fundamental problem of culture is spiritual not political.”

Southern Baptist pastor Tom Buck (First Baptist Church of Lindale, Texas), said, “I’m sick to my stomach to see how many in our country are committed to the culture of death. With this horrible economy, it should’ve been a red wave. But what matters most is keeping abortion proponents out of office! And that wasn’t a priority nationwide – even for Christians…Roe v Wade allowed many fake pro-life Christians to hide what they really believed. Those days are over!… Tragically, the red wave was the blood of innocent babies in many states.”

RELATED: Mohler on Conservatives’ Response to Pelosi Attack: ‘We Bear Responsibility for Weaponizing Language’

Thom Rainer: This Is What Is Necessary for Churches To Survive

Thom Rainer
Author photo taken by Allen Clark Photography, Copyright © 2014. All rights reserved.

Thom Rainer is the founder and CEO of Church Answers, as well as a popular speaker, professor, dean, and author. With nearly 40 years of ministry experience, including pastoring four churches and serving as interim pastor to 10 churches, he has spent a lifetime committed to the growth and health of the local church and its leaders. Thom’s latest book is, “I Am a Christian: Discovering What It Means to Follow Jesus Together with Fellow Believers.”

Other Ways to Listen to This Podcast With Thom Rainer

► Listen on Apple
► Listen on Spotify
► Listen on Stitcher
► Listen on YouTube

Key Questions for Thom Rainer

-How is our cultural moment impacting what you’re seeing in the church?

-What are some lessons church leaders have learned to make sure that their gatherings are meaningful, not transactional?

-What are some of the symptoms and the dangers of “loner Christianity”?

-What is your advice for pastors who are receiving people returning to church after having been deeply hurt by the church? 

Key Quotes From Thom Rainer

“There are two major moments—they’re not definitive moments, but they are moments that we need to look at. One is just the quarantine itself…The second thing is this really ambiguous phrase called ‘cultural Christianity.’”

“What I mean by ‘cultural Christianity’ is people who attend church for the cultural benefit. It could be a business person who wants to get more business. It could be a politician who wants more votes.”

“Cultural Christianity was waning before the pandemic. It is almost gone today. And that is true whether you’re looking at Spokane or Nashville.”

“Churches as a whole have abandoned evangelism. Now, that’s a broad, indicting statement, but it is a reality.”

“Bringing evangelism back into the regular rhythms of the local church is…critical not only to be obedient to the Great Commission, but for the survival of churches.”

“The local church is God’s primary Plan A for his mission, and we don’t see a Plan B.”

“We know biblically that those, even those who feel alienated, even those who are wondering if their faith has any foundation to it, we know biblically that they are ready to connect [with a church]…The problem is not the people to be reached. The problem is the people who are not reaching them.”

“‘The church is not a building; it’s the people.’—There’s an implication behind that [phrase]. It is biblically correct. The church is not a building. It’s the people. But there’s an implication and usually there’s a statement behind the statement…[that] it doesn’t matter if we’re in community because we are still the church.”

Megachurch Leads the Way in Ethnically Diverse Merger

Photo courtesy of Baptist Press.

LA VERGNE, Tenn. (BP) — Brady Cooper, senior pastor of New Vision Baptist Church in Murfreesboro, Tenn., received advice from a mentor that came in handy as the church sought to help revitalize First Baptist Church of LaVergne, a church about 20 minutes north of New Vision.

“Before you go making big decisions, look around and see what God’s doing.”

In a model the megachurch had never before undertaken, it led First Baptist LaVergne, a struggling Anglo congregation, to merge with Las Americas, a vibrant Hispanic congregation renting worship space at First LaVergne. The merger remains a congregation autonomous from New Vision.

The move came as New Vision took note of God’s handiwork, New Vision Executive Pastor Greg Freeman told Baptist Press Nov. 8.

First LaVergne needed a pastor. The congregation of about 50 worshipers, all of them retired, was heavily in debt. Interim Pastor Todd Tanner, vice president and chief administrative officer of the Tennessee Baptist Foundation, wanted to retain his position with the foundation.

On Easter of 2022, Las Americas, a vibrant Hispanic church of about 100 members led by Nathan Velasquez, moved from Franklin to LaVergne and began renting worship space at First LaVergne. The church made the move, Velasquez said, to be closer to where most of its members lived.

“That was a really good decision because the doubled the amount of attendance in two months,” Velasquez said.

Three months later, with the approval of First LaVergne’s membership, New Vision sent a team of about 40 church members to attend, work and tithe at First LaVergne. The revitalization team could stay at First LaVergne as long as they wanted, even join, Freeman said.

RELATED: Racial Unity Still a Focus Years After N.C. Church Merger

With about 6,400 members, a Sunday worship attendance of 2,000 and yearly undesignated receipts of nearly $10 million, according to Southern Baptist Convention Annual Church Profile data, New Vision was in a position to help First Baptist LaVergne as the smaller church retained its autonomy.

“To send people out to be a part of an autonomous church in any kind of magnitude like this, this is new for us,” Freeman said. “I think it just goes back to the heart of our senior pastor. The Lord has blessed us. Definitely, He’s done a great work here. … It’s not what we’ve done; it’s what God’s done.”

Even before New Vision sent the revitalization team to First LaVergne, the larger church helped the LaVergne congregation develop its youth ministry before the COVID-19 pandemic. New Vision viewed First LaVergne as an important congregation in a community with a high level of lostness that needed to retain the Southern Baptist church, Freeman said.

As New Vision considered First LaVergne’s need for a fulltime pastor, Velasquez caught New Vision’s eye.

“We learned through observation and just through being engaged with him, what a good leader he is,” Freeman said of Velasquez. “Las Americas has grown and we see the fruit of that ministry growth. It kind of just began to dawn that First Baptist could undertake a search for a pastor, that would be fine. But there’s a pastor here.”

New Vision proposed a merger of the two smaller congregations with Velasquez as senior pastor. The merger officially launches in January, 2023 as Community Church of LaVergne.

“It’s a little piece of heaven,” Velasquez told Baptist Press, “because we have seen different ethnicities all together, worshiping God and working together. And the best part of it is proof that we can do everything even when we are different.

“For me, it has been a blessing from day one,” he said, “the way First Baptist Church of LaVergne has been open, and merciful and kind.”

Velasquez will continue two worship services, one in English and one in Spanish, but will lead the church in combined fellowship, missions and education. He is working with members to establish the leadership structure and had not decided who will lead the English worship when he spoke with Baptist Press. He plans to hold English worship at 9:30 a.m., he said, and the Hispanic worship at 11:30 a.m.

“Differences are not a reason to be apart. We can be one family respecting our differences,” he said. “And we can enjoy because we have more things in common than different. Language is not a barrier, because the best language is the love of God.”

Tanner, who had served as interim pastor of First LaVergne since November, 2021, appreciates the transition.

Boston Pays Out $2.1M To Settle Christian Flag Legal Case

Christian Flag
FILE - The Christian Flag is raised at City Hall Plaza in Boston, Aug. 3, 2022. The city of Boston has agreed to pay more than $2.1 million to the Christian legal organization that backed a court challenge after the city refused to fly a Christian flag outside City Hall, a case that made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. (Stuart Cahill/The Boston Herald via AP, File)

BOSTON (AP) — The city of Boston has agreed to pay more than $2.1 million to the Christian legal organization that backed a court challenge after the city refused to fly a Christian flag outside City Hall, a case that made it all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

The settlement announced Tuesday by Liberty Counsel covers attorneys’ fees and other costs associated with the legal battle that started in 2017 when city resident Hal Shurtleff and his Camp Constitution group asked to hoist the flag on one of three poles on City Hall Plaza to mark Constitution Day.

“We are pleased that after five years of litigation and a unanimous victory at the U.S. Supreme Court, we joined with Hal Shurtleff to finally let freedom fly in Boston, the Cradle of Liberty,” Liberty Counsel founder and Chairman Mat Staver said in a statement.

The U.S., state and city flags usually fly outside the building, but the city flag is sometimes taken down and temporarily replaced with another.

Between 2005 and 2017, the city approved 284 consecutive applications from private organizations to fly flags, with no denials, before it rejected Shurtleff’s proposal, Liberty Counsel said.

RELATED: Boston City Hall Flies Christian Flag Following Supreme Court Ruling

The Supreme Court unanimously ruled in May that the city violated the free speech rights of Shurtleff because of his “religious viewpoint.”

The Christian flag — which is white, with a red cross on a blue background in the upper left corner — finally flew for a couple hours outside City Hall on Aug. 3 as activists cheered and sang songs of praise.

The city has since passed an ordinance that clarifies the rules for flag raisings.

Liberty Counsel was entitled to attorneys’ fees as the prevailing party in the case, the city said in a statement.

The city’s Law Department determined $2.125 million to be reasonable based on billing statements provided by Liberty Counsel and through their own analysis, the statement said.

“Settlement at this time also allows the City to avoid the costs and uncertainty associated with further litigation in this case,” the city statement said.

The case has established precedent, Liberty Counsel’s Staver said, “including the overturning of the 1971 ‘Lemon Test,’ which Justice (Antonin) Scalia once described as a ‘ghoul in a late night horror movie.’ The case of Shurtleff v. City of Boston finally buried this ghoul that haunted the First Amendment for 51 years.”

This article originally appeared here.

Despite Doug Mastriano’s Loss, Don’t Count Out Christian Nationalism

Doug Mastriano
Pennsylvania Republican gubernatorial candidate Doug Mastriano speaks ahead of former President Donald Trump at a rally in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania, Sept. 3, 2022. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer, File)

(RNS) — Pennsylvania state Sen. Doug Mastriano’s bid for governor wasn’t exactly an effort many of his fellow Republican candidates were looking to emulate. He oversaw a campaign that shunned the mainstream media, spent little on traditional advertising and didn’t raise much cash to do so.

It was an unorthodox approach that appears to have fallen far short of a winning formula: On election night on Tuesday (Nov. 8), multiple news networks declared that Mastriano lost to his state’s attorney general, Josh Shapiro.

But political operatives were keeping an eye on Mastriano for at least one reason: how the Pennsylvanian deployed Christian nationalist themes to secure the hard-line religious right base. Mastriano broke out of the Republican primary pack by cloaking himself in one of the most vocal strains of Christian nationalism: anti-pandemic restrictions, pro-conspiracy theories about the 2020 election and dubious of separation of church and state.

As the GOP nominee, Mastriano rejected the label of Christian nationalist, but he regularly sprinkled his speeches with religious references — one of his campaign slogans, “Walk as a free people,” is a reference to the Gospel of John. When a rainbow appeared in the background during one of his final stump speeches, Mastriano’s campaign framed it as a sign from God. With Christian nationalism on the rise in this election cycle, Mastriano’s campaign became a test case for the maximum bet on the ideology.

RELATED: How Doug Mastriano Uses Faith To Fend Off Criticism—Even From Other Christians

But now that Mastriano’s campaign is grappling with defeat, what does his loss say about the purported surge of Christian nationalism among Republicans?

Samuel Perry, a University of Oklahoma sociologist and co-author of “The Flag and the Cross: White Christian Nationalism and the Threat to American Democracy,” argued that Mastriano’s campaign represented more of Christian nationalism’s fringe than of its broader appeal.

“His public appearances are bizarre, his statements are extremist,” Perry said in a statement to Religion News Service, “and some of his known associates (like Gab CEO Andrew Torba) would be radioactive to most Americans.”

Even so, Perry said, Mastriano’s win in the gubernatorial primary speaks to the power wielded by Christian nationalism’s hard-liners.

“The fact that he hasn’t been blown out of the water since day one tells the radical Christian nationalist fringe — the kind that would support arresting women who have abortions, or overturn Obergefell, or institutionalize Christian supremacy — that their views are finding resonance among enough people to where they can just keep trying,” Perry said.

Anthea Butler, chair of religious studies at the University of Pennsylvania, agreed that despite his poor showing on Election Day, Mastriano’s loss is unlikely to stop appeals to Christian nationalism. “I think we’re just at the beginning of this effort, given the recent books and talks that evangelicals have been promoting,” Butler said in an email.

Butler noted too that Christian nationalism will get a boost if former President Donald Trump enters the presidential race. In recent days Trump fed expectations that he will announce a third White House bid as soon as next week.

“The embrace of Christian Nationalism works well with MAGA, and with Trump’s potential announcement for President, I don’t think that it is going to go away any time soon,” Butler said. “Mastriano is just one of many candidates who find purchase with Christian nationalism.”

Andrew Whitehead, a sociologist who wrote 2020’s “Taking America Back for God: Christian Nationalism in the United States” with Perry, said the power of Christian nationalism may be better judged among smaller constituencies.

RELATED: Examples of Christian Nationalism Are the ‘Greatest Argument’ Against It, Says Southern Baptist Ethics Professor

“Winning a race like Mastriano’s in Pennsylvania, leaning on Christian nationalism, is harder than, perhaps, a congressional seat in the South,” Whitehead said.

Whether Christian nationalism helps or hurts a candidate, party operatives may not have much control over the movement’s power, Whitehead said. “Because voters in primaries are usually the most motivated, and strong supporters of Christian nationalism are very motivated, candidates who embrace Christian nationalism may continue to win nominations even if they sometimes lose general elections,” he said.

This article originally appeared here.

855,266FansLike

New Articles

New Podcasts

Joby Martin

Joby Martin: What Happens When Pastors Finally Understand Grace

Joby Martin joins “The Stetzer ChurchLeaders Podcast” to discuss what happens when a church leader has truly been run over by the “grace train" and understands the profound love and grace of God.